The Williams Insurance Agency, Inc. Team

Contact Our Licensed Insurance Agents & Customer Services Representatives for Peace of Mind at a Reasonable Price

The Williams Insurance Agency, Inc. is here to assist you by offering comprehensive personal, business, and employee benefits packages. Our team is committed to assisting you by helping protect your assets by providing access to reputable companies with strong financial bases. Each of our insurance companies offer a wide variety of quality products to help you achieve your personal and business goals. We offer peace of mind at a reasonable price.


Contact Our Insurance Agents

Seth Costello CIC – Chief Operating Officer – Managing Partner
Commercial Lines Producer

Tel: 302-227-2501 Ext. 224

20220 Coastal Highway Rehoboth Beach, DE 19971

Patty Walker CIC – Vice President – Commercial Lines Producer

Tel: 302-227-2501 Ext. 229

20220 Coastal Highway Rehoboth Beach, DE 19971

Michael V. Buchler – Vice President – Director of Employee Benefits Division

Tel: 302-239-5500 Ext. 109

4550 Linden Hill Road, Linden Park, Suite 303, Wilmington, DE 19808

Anthony DiMarzo – Vice President – Commercial Lines Producer

Tel: 302-239-5500 Ext. 110

4550 Linden Hill Road, Linden Park, Suite 303, Wilmington, DE 19808

Travers Downes – Vice President, Agency Development – Commercial Lines Producer

Tel: 302-227-2501 Ext. 259

20220 Coastal Highway Rehoboth Beach, DE 19971

John B. Curtis CIC CRM – Benefits Producer

Tel: 302-239-5500 Ext. 112

4550 Linden Hill Road, Linden Park, Suite 303, Wilmington, DE 19808

Robin VanBruggen AU CIC – Personal and Commercial Lines Producer

Tel: 302-227-2501 Ext. 215

20220 Coastal Highway Rehoboth Beach, DE 19971

Janet Stevenson Dunn – Personal Lines Producer

Tel: 302-227-2501 Ext. 230

20220 Coastal Highway Rehoboth Beach, DE 19971

Chuck Riley – Personal and Commercial Lines Producer

Tel: 302-227-2501 Ext. 247

20220 Coastal Highway Rehoboth Beach, DE 19971

Steven Harvey – Personal and Commercial Lines Producer

Tel: 302-227-2501 Ext. 254

20220 Coastal Highway Rehoboth Beach, DE 19971

Lori Shue – Personal Lines Producer

Tel: 302-227-2501 Ext. 246

20220 Coastal Highway Rehoboth Beach, DE 19971

Jamie Jenney – Benefits Producer

Tel: 302-239-5500 Ext. 102

4550 Linden Hill Road, Linden Park, Suite 303, Wilmington, DE 19808

Contact Our Customer Service Representatives

Jennifer White – Commercial Lines Account Manager

Tel: 302-227-2501 Ext 212

20220 Coastal Highway Rehoboth Beach, DE 19971

Christina Sargent – Commercial Lines Account Manager

Tel: 302-227-2501 Ext 216

20220 Coastal Highway Rehoboth Beach, DE 19971

Rachel Young – Personal Lines Account Manager

Tel: 302-227-2501 Ext 232

20220 Coastal Highway Rehoboth Beach, DE 19971

Erin Holgerson – Commercial Lines Account Manager

Tel: 302-227-2501 Ext 220

20220 Coastal Highway Rehoboth Beach, DE 19971

Melissa Kelley – Commercial Lines Account Manager

Tel: 302-227-2501 Ext 221

20220 Coastal Highway Rehoboth Beach, DE 19971

Debbie Kolodjeski – Benefits Account Manager

Tel: 302-239-5500 Ext. 113

4550 Linden Hill Road, Linden Park, Suite 303, Wilmington, DE 19808

Marianne Pistoria – Benefits Account Manager

Tel: 302-239-5500 Ext 106

4550 Linden Hill Road, Linden Park, Suite 303, Wilmington, DE 19808

Angela Wells – Personal Lines Account Manager

Tel: 302-239-5500 Ext. 100

4550 Linden Hill Road, Linden Park, Suite 303, Wilmington, DE 19808

Jason Clarke – Commercial Lines Account Manager

Tel: 302-239-5500 Ext. 103

4550 Linden Hill Road, Linden Park, Suite 303, Wilmington, DE 19808

Marie Hogle – Commercial Lines Account Manager

Tel: 302-239-5500 Ext. 108

4550 Linden Hill Road, Linden Park, Suite 303, Wilmington, DE 19808

Briana Benenati – Commercial Lines Service Agent

Tel: 302-227-2501 Ext. 220

20220 Coastal Highway Rehoboth Beach, DE 19971

Tammi Toliver – Personal Lines Account Manager

Mary Ann Rork – Personal Lines Account Manager

Katie Reese – Personal Lines Account Manager

Sheila Wells – Marketing Department Manager – Commercial Lines Account Manager

Sarah Dillon – Commercial Lines Account Manager

Tel: 302-239-5500 ext. 107

4550 Linden Hill Road, Linden Park, Suite 303, Wilmington, DE 19808

Contact Our Claims Agents

Michelle Axselle – Director of Claims Operations

Tel: 302-227-2501 Ext 239

20220 Coastal Highway Rehoboth Beach, DE 19971

Tina Muscara – Claims Agent

Tel: 302-239-5500 Ext 111

4550 Linden Hill Road, Linden Park, Suite 303, Wilmington, DE 19808


Contact the Williams Insurance Agency, Inc. in Rehoboth Beach, Delaware, at 302-227-2501 or in Wilmington, Delaware, at 302-239-5500. Our agents are available to provide personalized insurance products to meet all of your personal and business needs.